Plans for 5G mast 'will damage iconic castle view'
Plans for a 5G mast in the middle of the most photographed view of Edinburgh Castle have been described as "damaging" by a conservation charity.
An application has been lodged to erect the 17m (56ft) structure on Johnston Terrace, which passes below the castle.
Mobile network Three UK says the mast is "vital" and will not spoil the view.
But the plans have sparked more than 160 objections, with The Cockburn Association among those calling for an alternative solution to be found.
Terry Levinthal is director of the association, Scotland's oldest conservation charity.
He told BBC Scotland it was "unacceptable" to erect a mast in such a significant location.
"The castle is one of Edinburgh and Scotland's most historic and iconic heritage sites and tourist destinations," he said.
"It [a mast] will inevitably have a significant and negative impact on views to and from Edinburgh Castle and the Old Town.
"A mast would visually damage it and therefore damage the context of Edinburgh. An alternative solution is needed as this is unacceptable."
He acknowledged that effective telecommunications were needed in the city - but said the mast should be located in a "more inconspicuous" spot.
It is proposed to site the mast in Johnston Terrace, which runs just below the castle rock at the top of Granny's Green Steps.
Many city tours stop in the Grassmarket area so that visitors can capture the view looking up at the castle.
Chris Sandeman, who runs a free walking tour, said he was "saddened and disgusted" by the plans.
He said: "I can see the argument for it, as there should be the option to have reception in the city centre - but this mast would destroy an iconic view.
"It is very short-sighted to obstruct a view which makes money for Edinburgh.
"We take all our tours there to photograph Edinburgh Castle and they then post it on social media, which helps to promote the capital."
Iain Ponton, who owns the Oz Bar in Candlemaker Row, said the mast would "stick out like a sore thumb beside such an historic site".
A spokeswoman for Historic Environment Scotland, which manages Edinburgh Castle, said it had not been consulted about the plans.
The application will now be considered by City of Edinburgh Council.
The mast is being proposed by CK Hutchison Networks to help provide coverage for Three UK's network.
A Three UK spokesman said: "The high footfall at this popular tourist destination means that the extra capacity provided by our 5G rollout is vital for residents, visitors and businesses of Johnston Terrace.
"We want to offer the community a reliable network experience and this site will be critical to making that happen.
"Masts need to be situated where people will be using the service and, in many cases, in precise locations to ensure the widest breadth of coverage.
"We carry out extensive searches and evaluate a wide range of options before submitting any planning applications and we are sure that both visitors and locals will still be able to enjoy clear views of Edinburgh Castle."
-
Classified documents found at former VP Mike Pence's home included briefing papers for foreign visits He's back at it! Fyre Festival fraudster Billy McFarland utilizes whiteboard and poster to launch new virtual PYRT festival - and for $250 you can attend from your BEDROOM!'It's the most devastating day of our lives': Family's tribute to hero Jack, 10, who 'died trying to save three boys he didn't know' after they fell into frozen lake - as vigil marks tragedy in SolihullBREAKING NEWS: Manchester United CONFIRM the loan signing of Wout Weghorst until the end of the seaconsequentlyn - as Red Devils pay Besiktas £2.5m to cut fleeting his spell in Turkey World champion Max Verstappen recovers from pit-speak disaster to overtake Lewis Hamilton and WIN the United States Grand Prix... landing the constructors' title for Red Bull on emotional weekendPICTURED: The six airmen who died during Veterans Day 'Wings over Dallas' demonstrate when B-17 COLLIDED midair with Bell P-63 Kingcobra, as spectators watched in horror - experienced pilots were captains for American Airlines and United 'F*** you Ted Cruz, you climate denying piece of s***': Moment security guard drags eco activist from The View audience after disrupting the demonstrateElon Musk REINSTATES Donald Trump's Twitter account after holding poll on whether to bring him back: Ex-president's account has lost 89 MILLION followers - but all his old tweets are still there IMF expects UK economy to shun recessionUS judge DROPS lawsuit accusing Saudi Crown Prince MBS of the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi - after Biden administration said he should have immunity
Next article:Jessica Pegula eases past Barbora Krejcikova to seal Australian Open quarter-final spot... and American is now the HIGHEST seeded woman left in the tournament
- ·Why food bills aren't shrinking
- ·Deliveroo rider is killed in gangland bloodbath... just weeks before flight home to Brazil: Innocent man dies in crash with car before driver leaps out and is shot by rival in pursuing vehicle - as shooter remains on run
- ·Amazon plans to shut three UK wareho utilizes with 1,200 jobs at risk: Retail giant says workers will be offered roles at other locations as it unveils proposals for two new fulfilment centres to create 2,500 roles over three years
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Single-engine plane crashes into New Hampshire acomponentment erecting killing EVERYONE on board and sending 40-foot flames leaping into the sky
- ·Virgin Orbit: Branconsequentlyn’s rocket dream ends after mission failure
- ·Elon Musk to welcome Trump back to Twitter, reverses lifetime bans
- ·Florida medical board BANS puberty blockers for minors under the age of 18 - after hearing testimony from 'de-transitioners'
- ·Steve Bannon gets FOUR MONTHS in priconsequentlyn for defying January 6 subpoena: Defiant Trump adviconsequentlyr leaves court and tears into Biden's 'illegitimate regime', Nancy Pelosi and Liz Cheney - and says November 8 will be 'judgment day'
- ·ISIS-inspired terrorist who killed eight people with truck in NYC is convicted - and could face first death penalty in New York since 1963
- ·Times Square 'jihadi', 19, was arrested with chilling manifesto: Told consequentlyldier brother 'you joined ranks of my enemy', ordered family to convert to Islam to shun 'hellfire' - and apologized to mother for 'not having been a good enough consequentlyn'
- ·Asconsequentlyciated Press fires reporter behind retracted story that a US official said Russian missiles had come down in Poland
- ·January 6 committee 'believes Trump should be charged with at least THREE crimes from riot'- including insurrection': Panel to vote Monday on referring him for prosecution
- ·Loose Women's Denise Welch pays tribute to 'wonderful actress' Josephine Melville, 61, who played Tessa Parker in the 1980s after she died backstage at play
- ·Man assaulted with a samurai sword at Manhattan subway station
- ·Israel acc utilizes Iran of assaulting tanker off Oman using same kind of kamikaze drone sent by Tehran to help Russia pound Ukraine
- ·Texas Longhorns men's basketball coach Chris Beard is arrested for 'strangling family member' and faces third-degree assault charge
- ·FBI responds to 'barricade situation' inside Fort Belvoir Army base in Virginia
- ·Where's the outrage? Homeless man with 25 prior arrests is perp walked after 'raping jogger, 43, in Manhattan's West Village' - as New York governor and mayor BOTH remain silent on horrific crime
- ·World champion Max Verstappen recovers from pit-speak disaster to overtake Lewis Hamilton and WIN the United States Grand Prix... landing the constructors' title for Red Bull on emotional weekend
- ·Multiple Ukrainian embassies receive 'bloody packages' containing ANIMAL EYES after consulate in Spain received letter bomb
- ·REVEALED: Rapper, 49, was escorting gang member, 18, out of Des Moines school he founded when teenager 'suddenly opened fire' - killing two students who were members of rival gang
- ·World Cup star man Kylian Mbappe misses France training, four days before quarter-final clash with England, after grumbleing of an ankle injury pre-tournament
- ·Supreme Court says Lindsey Graham MUST testify to Georgia grand jury in the criminal investigation into efforts to overturn the 2020 election
- ·Paul Pelosi made secret 911 call after confronting assaulter in his home: Police dispatch recordings reveal he spoke in 'code' as he said he didn't know who intruder was but that he 'is a friend'
- ·Train strikes this week to hit FA Chigh final and Epconsequentlym Derby
- ·Crypto giant Genesis files for bankruptcy after suffering crippling losses in wake of FTX collapse - and has over 100,000 creditors
- ·Woman is arrested on suspicion of murder after man in his 60s was found unresponsive in Tesco car park and later died following 'robbery of his mobility scooter' in Cotswolds
- ·January 6 committee 'believes Trump should be charged with at least THREE crimes from riot'- including insurrection': Panel to vote Monday on referring him for prosecution
- ·National champion Georgia's offensive lineman Devin Willock and recruiting staffer die in a 2.45am car crash less than 24 hours after the Bulldogs' victory parade
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Detroit Pistons 'place assistant general manager Rob Murphy on leave after launching an investigation into an allegation of workplace misconduct involving a female former employee'
- ·Network Rail says infrastructure will get less reliable
- ·Third man, 18, is charged with murder over nightclub dancefloor stabbing of footballer Cody Fisher
- ·Embattled Commanders owner Dan Snyder, 57, backtracks and is now takeing selling all or consequentlyme of the '$5.6b' team - after years of losing and scandals over the club name and sexual harassment claims
- ·Biden 'is a tyrant': Furious Republicans say President's 'patronizing' speech saying democracy is 'not the rule of monarchs' and the midterms a battle with MAGA 'dark compels' won't divide Americans and distract from his dire record
- ·Man assaulted with a samurai sword at Manhattan subway station
- ·Dad's anguish as he goes out to buy a new TV and returns home to find his mentally ill wife murdered their three children and killed herself - before he was then interrogated and shouted at by cops on the worst day of his life